Punch! CAD 
 »  
ViaCAD & Shark 
 »  
General 
 »  
Retain Solid Subtraction 
 
 
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/14/2014(UTC) Posts: 120
Thanks: 2 times Was thanked: 25 time(s) in 23 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                I am using CTRL on the 2nd selection. I pull that object away and see the subtraction, but as soon as I let go the subtraction adds itself back. Is this normal? Did I miss a step?
Edited by user  Tuesday, December 25, 2018 10:05:44 AM(UTC) 
 | Reason: Not specified 
    VCpro v11-1417  Win10Pro 32GB  Xeon E3-1270-v3 3.5GHz  Asrock Extreme 9ac  Samsung SSD RAID5  nvidia GTX760
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Guest
Joined: 5/24/2015(UTC) Posts: 12
Was thanked: 1 time(s) in 1 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Yes. You just removed the cylinder from the sphere so it is no longer intersecting the sphere. Therefore it can't be subtracted any more.
            
  
         
     
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/14/2014(UTC) Posts: 120
Thanks: 2 times Was thanked: 25 time(s) in 23 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Originally Posted by: mstevens  Yes. You just removed the cylinder from the sphere so it is no longer intersecting the sphere. Therefore it can't be subtracted any more.
But isnt use of CTRL-SELECT on 2nd object mean to subtract it from the 1st AND retain the 2nd object, thus allowing the subtraction to happen so I can then move my 2nd object? 
In 1st post, subtract would just create a hole. Subtract+retain (use of CTRL key on select) would bore the hole and you are left with a rod in the hole that was made in the sphere.
What would be the point of subtraction+retain if you cant move the 2nd object?
Here's the vid of a std subtraction (seems normal), the subtract-from (1st object selection) remains with the hole and the 2nd object is removed.
    VCpro v11-1417  Win10Pro 32GB  Xeon E3-1270-v3 3.5GHz  Asrock Extreme 9ac  Samsung SSD RAID5  nvidia GTX760
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 9/12/2009(UTC)
Posts: 609
Location: In my place
Was thanked: 59 time(s) in 51 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                ctrl-select means the 2nd object still appears on the screen thus it answers both your questions.  It leaves a rod in the hole but as soon as you move it around it will still keep subtracting.  If you move it away from the intersection, it won't subtract a thing.
in your third question you said what's the point if you can't move the 2nd object.  I'm not sure where this is going and you are contradicting yourself.  In your first video, you moved it so it is possible to move it.
Originally Posted by: CNC_Kid  Originally Posted by: mstevens  Yes. You just removed the cylinder from the sphere so it is no longer intersecting the sphere. Therefore it can't be subtracted any more.
But isnt use of CTRL-SELECT on 2nd object mean to subtract it from the 1st AND retain the 2nd object, thus allowing the subtraction to happen so I can then move my 2nd object? 
In 1st post, subtract would just create a hole. Subtract+retain (use of CTRL key on select) would bore the hole and you are left with a rod in the hole that was made in the sphere.
What would be the point of subtraction+retain if you cant move the 2nd object?
Here's the vid of a std subtraction (seems normal), the subtract-from (1st object selection) remains with the hole and the 2nd object is removed.
    FX 7-FXPro14-1650 
MacPro 11.7.4 
2x2.8GHz Quad Xeon 32GB 
NVIDIA 4 K5000 4GB 
Work  
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/14/2014(UTC) Posts: 120
Thanks: 2 times Was thanked: 25 time(s) in 23 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Originally Posted by: rockyroad_us  ctrl-select means the 2nd object still appears on the screen thus it answers both your questions.  It leaves a rod in the hole but as soon as you move it around it will still keep subtracting.  If you move it away from the intersection, it won't subtract a thing. in your third question you said what's the point if you can't move the 2nd object.  I'm not sure where this is going and you are contradicting yourself.  In your first video, you moved it so it is possible to move it.
My point was, if I make a CTRL-select subtraction then what's the point of doing the subtraction of two intersecting solids if after I do subtraction I leave everything as-is?
I want to make subtraction and then move my subtracting solid somewhere else to make another subtraction on another object, etc.
    VCpro v11-1417  Win10Pro 32GB  Xeon E3-1270-v3 3.5GHz  Asrock Extreme 9ac  Samsung SSD RAID5  nvidia GTX760
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 3/21/2017(UTC)
Posts: 971
Thanks: 47 times Was thanked: 339 time(s) in 225 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                It's just control to drag copy using the gripper. So you put your subtraction shape in, hold control drag out a copy of it, and move it to a new position to subtract again. Is this what you are doing? 
            
  
         
     
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 9/12/2009(UTC)
Posts: 609
Location: In my place
Was thanked: 59 time(s) in 51 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                right, you need to drag duplicate with the gripper or duplicate with history and put it wherever you want to subtract again.  Alternatively, you can break associativity of the subtraction and  can drag the cylinder if you don't want to copy.
    FX 7-FXPro14-1650 
MacPro 11.7.4 
2x2.8GHz Quad Xeon 32GB 
NVIDIA 4 K5000 4GB 
Work  
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
                           
Punch! CAD 
 »  
ViaCAD & Shark 
 »  
General 
 »  
Retain Solid Subtraction 
 
    
        Forum Jump
         
Punch! CAD 
  ViaCAD & Shark 
   - News and Announcements 
   - General 
   - 2D Drafting 
   - Surface Modeling 
   - Solid Modeling 
   - Subdivision Modeling 
   - Rendering & Display 
   - Import/Export 
   - Tips and Tutorials 
   - Suggestions 
   - Gallery 
   - PowerPack 
   - Punch Lounge 
 
    
    You cannot  post new topics in this forum.
 
You cannot  reply to topics in this forum.
 
You cannot  delete your posts in this forum.
 
You cannot  edit your posts in this forum.
 
You cannot  create polls in this forum.
 
You cannot  vote in polls in this forum.