Punch! CAD 
 »  
ViaCAD & Shark 
 »  
Solid Modeling 
 »  
ellipsoid solid primitive subtraction problem 
 
 
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/16/2015(UTC) Posts: 351
Thanks: 49 times Was thanked: 43 time(s) in 30 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                starting with a primitive ellipsoid solid,  a solid cylinder is created such that one of the ends of the cylinder passes through the center of the ellipsoid.  the solid cylinder is subtracted from the solid ellipsoid 
expecting  to get half of an ellipsoid.   instead something closer to a quarter of the ellipsoid is left.................   anyone have any idea(s) on what might be going on.  I don't "need" have of an ellipsoid;  it was being created to support "process development" (aka: operator training) for 
bending  of tapered asymmetric sections about an axis not passing through the section.  thanks in advance for an idea(s) or suggestion(s)
Art
artesmith@earthlink.net Art Smith attached the following image(s):
 ellipsoid substraction problem.jpg 
(49kb) downloaded 13  time(s). You cannot  view/download attachments. Try to login or register.
 
            
  
         
     
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 12/21/2014(UTC)
Posts: 214
Thanks: 4 times Was thanked: 26 time(s) in 22 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                I always try to reproduce a problem  - that's learning by doing.
To substract the cylinder from the ellipsoid is running always well for me. I have build the parts on different ways but there is no issue.
Additional I have learned, that I can cut out a ring of the ellipsoid when it is looking through the cylinder on both ends. By holding the Control-Key all parts stay over.
H.
ViaCAD V 9 Prof version
Edited by user  Monday, December 7, 2015 2:42:49 AM(UTC) 
 | Reason: Not specified 
    ViaCAD 9 Pro german + ViaCAD 10 Pro & PowerPack + ViaCAD 11, Win7Prof 64 Bit upgraded to Win 10 64 Bit, upgrated to Win 11 
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/16/2015(UTC) Posts: 351
Thanks: 49 times Was thanked: 43 time(s) in 30 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Horst-
thanks!   
based on your post I tried creating the cylinder "on-axis" and the subtraction yields the expected result !  initially I'd created the cylinder "off-axis" to make sure the correct plane was created after creating the solid ellipsoid.  may be a case of an "on-axis" algorithm being used with a missing translation to "on-axis"......
Art
artesmith@earthlink.net   
            
  
         
     
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 2/2/2007(UTC)
Posts: 5,450
Was thanked: 508 time(s) in 354 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Hi Art FYI, I have a bug report logged in with Spatial regarding booleans with ellipsoids. Tim
    Tim Olson  IMSI Design/Encore
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 1/16/2015(UTC) Posts: 351
Thanks: 49 times Was thanked: 43 time(s) in 30 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                Tim-
thanks for closing the loop!   not a big deal all things considered since the work around is so easy.
Art
artesmith@earthlink.net  
            
  
         
     
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
            
        
            
            
    
        
Rank: Senior Member
Joined: 2/2/2007(UTC)
Posts: 5,450
Was thanked: 508 time(s) in 354 post(s)
 
     
    
        
            
	      
                FYI, Spatial confirmed they could repeat this evening.  They are looking into a correction. Tim
    Tim Olson  IMSI Design/Encore
 
            
 
        
    
 
    
        
            
     
    
        
            
        
     
 
    
        
     
 
            
        
    
                           
Punch! CAD 
 »  
ViaCAD & Shark 
 »  
Solid Modeling 
 »  
ellipsoid solid primitive subtraction problem 
 
    
        Forum Jump
         
Punch! CAD 
  ViaCAD & Shark 
   - News and Announcements 
   - General 
   - 2D Drafting 
   - Surface Modeling 
   - Solid Modeling 
   - Subdivision Modeling 
   - Rendering & Display 
   - Import/Export 
   - Tips and Tutorials 
   - Suggestions 
   - Gallery 
   - PowerPack 
   - Punch Lounge 
 
    
    You cannot  post new topics in this forum.
 
You cannot  reply to topics in this forum.
 
You cannot  delete your posts in this forum.
 
You cannot  edit your posts in this forum.
 
You cannot  create polls in this forum.
 
You cannot  vote in polls in this forum.